War changed dramatically in 1911 when the Italians used the first aircraft for reconnaissance during the Turkish war.
That opened a whole realm of opportunities in war, and in stretching what was thought to be possible, the fighter aircraft was born.
This drastically changed how wars would be fought in the future, as well as creating a new space in which we could fight.
Thus, the term dog fight was born and the sky became the golden nugget everyone wanted to control.
It has been said those who control the sky, control the land.
Today we will go head to head on two of the most iconic fighter jets known, the F-16 “Fighting Falcon” and the F-18 “Super Hornet”.
Related Article – Becoming A Pilot in the Air National Guard: 5 Steps
F-16 Vs. F-18: Top 10 Differences
The F-16 Fighting Falcon (AKA ‘Viper’) can reach impressive top speeds just over Mach 1.7, which is over 1,300 MPH!
The average cruising speed is 577 MPH.
The F-18 Hornet can reach a top speed of Mach 1.5, which translates to 1,190 MPH.
Its cruising speed varies between 580 KTS at high altitude, to 720 KTS at low altitude.
So in a drag race the F-16 takes the cake every time, giving it a unique speed advantage.
In more realistic flying conditions, such as getting to and from a target, the F-18 would get there faster due to its higher cruising speed.
The F-16 fighting falcon, which is manufactured by General Dynamics and Lockheed Martin, is a single engine multi-role fighter originally created for the US Air Force.
It was designed to be a day fighter but evolved to be a multi tool of sorts, being used in whatever situation it was needed.
General Dynamics is the 4th largest military contractor in the world, and they have manufactured some very iconic weapons and aircraft used in warfare today.
They manufacture several types of aircraft, including the F-111 Aardvark.
They have been in business for 123 years, as they were founded in February of 1899.
McDonnell Douglas, on the other hand, was founded in 1967 but were acquired by their competitor (Boeing) in 1997.
Boeing was founded in 1916, and has become the second largest military contractor in the world.
Nearly 55% of their revenue comes from defense contracts, which amounts to around $58 Billion per year.
They produce a massive variety of aircraft, including the civilian passenger jets like the 747, 767, and 787.
They decided all civilian aircraft would start and end in a 7. They also make many bombers and fighter jets, including the B-52, F-15, and F-22.
Boeing also works in aerospace, working with satellites and space craft. Boeing also produces the latest missiles, tanks and unmanned vehicles for the US government as well.
They are currently working on several experimental aircraft, pushing the boundaries of what we know today to even greater heights.
The F-16 Falcon is a single engine jet, powered by a Pratt & Whitney F100-PW-220 or a General Electric F110 turbo fan engine.
With after burning, the powerful engine can create up to 29,000lbs of thrust (130 kilonewtons).
The F-18 is built different, having dual engines.
These engines are either the General Electric F-414 or the Turbo electric engines, built by McDonnell Douglas.
They can each produce up to 17,750 lbs of thrust (79 kilonewtons) with the afterburner lit.
Together they can produce up to 35,000 lbs of thrust, more than the F-16.
However, due to the excess weight and aerodynamic drag of the F-18, the F-16 is able to reach higher speeds.
With that said, since the F-18 has 2 engines, it gives it an advantage in the event of an engine failure.
If an F-16 experiences an engine failure, it will need to land immediately.
Related Article – Army Reserves Vs. National Guard
The F-16 is primarily used by the US Air Force (Reserve and active duty), the Navy as well as the National Guard.
The F-16 serves as a multi-purpose aircraft, being deployed in every theater of war the US has been involved in.
The F-16 is used to attack air fields, bunkers, military production facilities and are armed with various payloads to better accomplish missions.
It is one of the cheaper fighter jets in the current line up as of 2022.
The F-18, on the other hand, is currently utilized exclusively by the Navy and the Marine Corps.
They loved how universal the aircraft could be; being used for recon missions, bombing runs, air-to-air combat and air-to-ground firing runs.
The F-18 is also coveted for its lower than average maintenance costs.
The B model has been used primarily for training missions, whereas the C model has been utilized more for real world missions.
The F-18 D model is exclusively used by the US Marine Corps, and is essentially a 2 seat model of the F/A-18C.
Another large reason this was chosen by the Marines and Navy is due to it being able to take off and land on an aircraft carrier.
The F-16’s landing gear cannot handle the stress involved in carrier-based operations, and is confined to traditional runways.
Related Article – Navy Pilot Vs. Air Force Pilot
#5. Combat Roles
Both The F-16 and the F-18 can do varying mission types including air to air, air to ground, recon and surveillance.
They have both been adopted to fulfill any necessary combat situations and are used in various environmental settings.
The F-18 has some advantages in combat that the F-16 cannot match. It has the ability to take off from aircraft carriers, allowing a more tactical insert into the battle-space.
In addition, the F-18 has a longer combat range of 400 nautical miles, as opposed to the F-16’s combat range of 295 nautical miles.
This aircraft, although can do nearly any mission, has been used primarily for air-to-ground attacks, reconnaissance and as a tool to hold the sky during combat times.
It is used in dog fights as well, but has a shorter ranged reconnaissance and air-to-ground fire runs.
The F-16 has a greater range by far when compared to the F-18, meaning it can stay in the air much longer without the need to refuel while accomplishing a mission.
It also can handle more G forces than the F-18, so it has the advantage in a dog fight. It has the abilities to fly far and quickly, allowing a rapid takeover of the skies.
Through their differences both of these aircraft are used widely as whatever is needed in the moment, they are capable of handling multiple mission types and different loads of ordinance making them some of the most popular aircraft in the battle space toady.
The F-16 Falcon can handle impressive 9G maneuvers in the air giving it the ability to quickly change course and leave other aircraft to struggle to keep up.
The F-18 Hornet is capable of handling 7.5G’s which still allows for rapid maneuvers, just not quite as hard as those of a F-16.
Both jets can handle complex maneuvers though, both evasive and offensive, but the F-16 can go just a little more.
The design of the F-18 makes it a formidable opponent though in a dog fight due to its thrust to weight ratio as well as its dual engines.
This allows it to nearly perform the same maneuvers as the F-16 Falcon.
In a dog fight the F-16 would most likely wind up on top, but it wouldn’t be an easy fight in the least.
The F-16 Falcon Is a bit more compact when compared to the F-18 Hornet.
The F-16 has a length of 49 feet and 5 inches. Its wing span is 32 feet and 8 inches.
This aircraft has a takeoff weight of 37,500 lbs. The F-18 comes in slightly larger at 56 feet long with a wingspan of 40 feet and 4 inches.
It has a takeoff weight of over 40,000 lbs. The only thing about the F-16 that is larger than the F-18 is the height, it comes in just a few inches taller.
The reasoning behind the dimensions of these aircraft are for what its intended purpose was.
The F-16 is raw speed and power, able to be a smaller target and perform greater maneuvers.
The F-18 is more of a universal aircraft designed with two engines, making the weight and size of the craft larger than the single engine comparison.
This can allow it to carry more firepower into a mission than the F-16, which in some cases would prove more valuable than the speed and size of the F-26.
The F-16 costs roughly 30 million dollars per unit. The F-18 costs more than double at 66.9 million dollars.
You have to also think about the cost to keep these in the air when considering the price of these jets and the cost per hour to run an F-18 is $10,507.
This is most likely due to its dual engines eating fuel more rapidly than single engine aircraft.
The F-16 comes in a little cheaper at $8,000 per hour, proving this point further.
Considering overall cost, the F-18 is more to purchase and more to run.
This gets off set slightly due to the F-18’s renowned lower maintenance costs and easier access to vital internal components.
This means it is easier and quicker to make repairs and maintain vital components when compared to the F-16.
Less down time on a piece of equipment in combat is easily worth paying more for in most cases.
#9. Dogfight Capabilities
The F-16 has a range of 2,622 miles which is more than four times that of the F-18, having only a range of 600 miles.
This means that the F-16 can travel much further from a base to accomplish a mission, or stay in the fight longer than the F-18 which has more of a need to get in and out of the fight relatively quickly.
The service celling is also greater on the F-16, at 55,000 feet when compared to the 36,089 feet of the F-18.
Also the F-16 and reach G forces up to 9.0 and the F-18 can only reach up to 7.5.
This gives the F-16 the advantage in flight time, altitude and maneuverability.
Due to the F-18 having two engines if one is blown, it can limp its way back home where if the F-16 loses its only engine, the pilot will need to abandon the aircraft generally.
A downside of the F-16 is it cannot handle the forces of landing and take-off from an aircraft carrier.
This is something the F-18 has an advantage over. It may not fly as far, but it is more versatile.
The F-18 also carries a larger and more versatile array of weapons when compared to the F-16.
Overall, in a strict air-to-air dog fight the F-16 would generally win.
However, when you need something that can do it all, carry more ordinance and be more flexible on what it’s doing and where it is taking off from, the F-18 is going to be the aircraft of choice for most missions.
Both fighter jets are battle proven and have been in use for many years due to their tremendous capabilities.
They are both great aircraft for reconnaissance, dog fights, fire runs and just as a presence to maintain the control over the sky or a battle area.
The F-16 is widely known as a versatile, powerful and most importantly an affordable fighter jet and thus is used by many other countries around the world.
Users of this jet include: Bahrain, Belgium, Denmark, Egypt, Greece, Indonesia, Israel, Netherlands, Norway, Pakistan, South Korea, Poland, Portugal, Singapore, Taiwan, Thailand, Turkey, USA and Venezuela.
The F-18 is more expensive, slightly newer and less widely used.
This is largely due to it having more cost associated with the craft, but it is currently used by; Australia, Canada, Finland, Kuwait, Malaysia, Spain, Switzerland and the US.
References / Resources
- Air Force Delayed Entry Program (DEP): 8 Things To Know - November 26, 2022
- Can You Join The Navy With A GED? Yes! - November 23, 2022
- Military Support Welder: 10 Things You Need To Know - November 23, 2022